Court Fines Police N310m Over Illegal Detention Of Lawyer

A Delta State High Court sitting in Ozoro has imposed a fine of N310m against the Nigeria Police Force and its officers for unlawful arrest, harassment, and detention of a lawyer, Otedjere Jude.

In a judgment delivered by Justice E. O. Odebala, the court awarded N300m as compensation against the police for the unlawful arrest and detention of the lawyer from Sept. 29, 2025 to Sept. 30 2025.

The court also awarded N10m as the cost of litigation in favour of the applicant.

In the certified true copy of the judgment obtained by the News Agency of Nigeria (NAN), on Thursday, the case arose from a fundamental rights enforcement application filed by the lawyer against the police.

Respondents in the case are several police officers in Kwale; the Commissioner of Police, Delta State; the Inspector-General of Police; the Nigeria Police Force and the Police Service Commission.

The lawyer approached the court through an originating motion filed on Nov. 28, 2025, pursuant to Sections 33(1), 34, 35, 37, 40, 41 and 46(1 & 2) of the 1999 Constitution (as amended), Article 6 of the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights and the Fundamental Rights (Enforcement Procedure) Rules, 2009.

He challenged his arrest and detention at Kwale Police Station between Sept. 29, 2025 and Sept. 30, 2025, describing the action of the police as unconstitutional and a violation of his fundamental rights.

He sought the order of the court awarding N500m as damages for his unlawful arrest and detention and N20m cost of litigation against the respondents .

In the judgment, Justice Odebala held that the actions of the police amounted to a gross violation of the applicant’s rights.

“I held that the arrest and detention of the applicant by the Police at Kwale police station on Sept. 29, 2025 to Sept. 39, 2025 without justification amounts to infringement of his liberty and freedom of movement.

“The applicant did not commit any offence to warrant the respondent to arrest and detain the applicant or take any step that is inconsistent with the fundamental rights of the applicant as guaranteed and protected under the 1999 Constitution.

“Assuming but without conceding that the applicant was legally arrested pursuant to Section 35 (1) (c) of the 1999 Constitution the Respondents still flagrantly detained the applicant for unsustainable reasons.

‘While the Constitution provides for arrest on reasonable suspicion, such suspicion does not, I hold, amount to detention in anticipation of an arrest.’

“It is hereby declared that the arrest and detention of the applicant at the prompting and instigation of the 1st Respondent without any justification amounts to an infraction of the liberty and freedom of movement of the applicant and same is wrongful, unconstitutional, ultra vires and of no moment whatsoever,” the court ruled.

The judge noted that none of the respondents filed any counter-affidavit to challenge the facts placed before it by the applicant.

“I must state here with alacrity that none of the respondents filed a counter-affidavit to this instant application,” Justice Odebala stated.

Relying on Order VIII Rule 3 of the Fundamental Rights (Enforcement Procedure) Rules, 2009, the judge added that where a respondent fails to file a counter-affidavit, “the court shall presume that the respondent has accepted the facts as presented by the applicant.”

Justice Odebala also criticised attempts by the police to file last-minute applications to stop the delivery of judgment, describing such moves as unacceptable.

“It is settled law that once a case has been heard and adjourned for judgment, no application whatsoever no matter how cleverly it is phrased such as the two applications before me, cannot legally truncate or arrest the delivery of a judgment.

“It connotes brigandage and lawlessness, which the court abhorred,” he said.

The court, therefore, struck out the two applications filed by the respondents and awarded N5m cost against them.

At the instance of the applicant’s counsel, Chief K.O. Uwubiti (SAN), the court also struck out the criminal charge filed against the lawyer.

“The Charge in Suit No MK/1C/2025 Between Commissioner of Police v. Barr. Itedjere Jude; or any other charge in relation to this matter is hereby struck out,” the judge ordered.

In granting the substantive reliefs, Justice Odebala made an order of perpetual injunction restraining the police and their agents from “inviting, harassing, chasing, disturbing, intimidating or threatening to arrest and/or causing the detention of the applicant” over the subject matter of the suit.

Reacting to the judgment, Rockson Igelige, a lawyer and member of Nigeria Bar Association, Oleh branch in Delta said it is a confirmation that the rule of law is alive in Nigeria.

He said the judgment would serve as a deterrent to the police to desist from the unlawful detention of innocent Nigerians.

Igelige recalled that the NBA Oleh branch, the jurisdiction of the applicant, had written a petition to the Commissioner of Police, Delta against the Divisional Police Officer of Kwale, CSP John Gaga over the matter.

He said the NBA would follow up on the case to ensure that the judgment is implemented.